'Temptation Island' Just Had a Major First (Spoilers Ahead)
It's over for Temptation Island's Kaitlin Tufts and Hall Toledano. Hall ended his eight-year relationship with his fiancée in a brutal breakup that played out in Wednesday night's episode.
"I have always been lost," he confessed, before telling Kaitlin that he "never had a real emotional connection" with her and that he's tried his entire life to find that connection.
Related: Which Temptation Island Couples Are Still Together in 2023?
"You were the best person that I've ever met in my entire life, so I forced myself to go back to you and I have been lying to myself," Hall said.
"And to me," the fitness studio owner interjected.
"Absolutely. I know that," Hall acknowledged.
Hall also claimed that he "never saw true love in [her] eyes," including on the day he proposed to her.
Hall, who's broken up with Kaitlin before, admitted that he come back into her life because he thought she was the one, and proposed because he believed it was the right thing to do.
"My biggest fear is hurting you," he ironically said, to which Kaitlin replied, "And you've done it twice now."
"But I have to be happy," Hall continued, noting that she, too, deserves so much better.
Asked if he found someone in the house, Hall replied, "I have found..." "You're welcome for bringing you here then," Kaitlin told him.
Going on the show was Kaitlin's idea. The pair were Temptation Island's first-ever engaged couple. The Tauruses were together “on and off" for a total of eight years before splitting on the island.
The reality show wasn't the first time that Kaitlin had been caught off guard by Hall. Three years into their relationship, Kaitlin was blindsided when Hall broke up with her, but they ended up getting back together a year-and-a-half later.
"When we got back together he was like a different person," she said in a video introducing themselves. He added, "I definitely grew as a man. I know what I want now."
Temptation Island airs Wednesdays at 9 p.m. ET/PT on USA Network.
Next, The Reality Show You Should Binge-Watch, According to Astrology