Pull-Apart Christmas Wreath Appetizer Recipe

Leah Maroney

Sat, December 23, 2023 at 11:45 AM UTC

9 min read

pull apart wreath - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Gooey, cheesy, garlicky bread is always going to be a hit at a party. And if you add some festive embellishments it's sure to make the celebration even more special. This pull-apart Christmas wreath appetizer is easy to make (especially if you buy store-bought dough) and is full of flavor and holiday cheer.

Recipe developer Leah Maroney knows all the tricks for making this dish a success: Use mozzarella string cheese instead of shredded cheese in the dough balls, add garlic butter before and after baking, and use sun-dried tomato and rosemary for attractive seasonal garnishes on the wreath. She advises, "Make sure to use a flat, un-rimmed sheet pan for this recipe. They are typically larger and more square in shape, so you can fit the full-size round wreath easily. The un-rimmed sheet pan also makes it much easier to slide the wreath off of the pan and onto a serving tray or cutting board."

This is a perfect appetizer to make with kids. Set up an assembly line for stuffing and assembling the bread. It's also great to make ahead of time and freeze so it's ready for your holiday gatherings without extra fuss.

Gather Your Ingredients For This Pull-Apart Christmas Wreath Appetizer

ingredeints for pull apart wreath - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Making this delicious, cheesy pull-apart wreath starts with making a simple pizza dough. Yeast, water, flour, salt, and olive oil are mixed and then left to rise. If you're looking to save time, you can use store-bought pizza dough. Once the dough has risen it is divided into equal-sized balls and stuffed with chunks of cheese and slices of pepperoni. We like to use mozzarella string cheese sticks because they're easy to cut and easy to wrap into the dough. Use a small bowl as the center of your wreath and build the dough balls around it. You can play around with different-sized balls for different arrangements. Grated garlic and butter are melted together and spread over the wreath. Save half of it for spreading on post-bake with the addition of some parsley ... this is the secret to the most garlicky, irresistible bread. Spread the butter over the baked wreath and garnish with sun-dried tomatoes and rosemary for a holiday accent. Serve marinara sauce for dipping and dig in while it's hot.

Step 1: Soften The Yeast

softened yeast in bowl - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Add the yeast, 1 teaspoon salt, and olive oil to 1 ? cups warm water.

Step 2: Add The Flour

pizza dough - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

After the yeast dissolves add in the flour and stir until it is incorporated.

Step 3: Knead The Dough

dough ball in bowl - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Knead the dough for a few minutes by hand.

Step 4: Let The Dough Rise

risen dough - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Cover with plastic wrap and let rise 1 hour or until doubled in size.

Step 5: Slice The Cheese

cut up cheese - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Cut each string cheese into 4 equal pieces.

Step 6: Cube The Butter

cubed butter - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Cube the butter and place in a small bowl.

Step 7: Grate The Garlic

grated garlic - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Grate or press the garlic over the butter and add the remaining teaspoon of salt.

Step 8: Melt The Garlic Butter

melted garlic butter - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Microwave the garlic butter until melted, about 1 minute.

Step 9: Chop The Parsley

chopped parsley - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Chop the parsley.

Step 10: Prepare The Baking Sheet

baking sheet lined with parchment paper - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Line an unrimmed baking sheet with parchment paper and place a small bowl in the center.

Step 11: Prepare The Dough

Unwrap the dough and turn it onto a floured surface.

Step 12: Cut The Dough

dough cut into small pieces - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Cut the dough into equal-sized pieces, about 24 total.

Step 13: Stuff With Pepperoni And Cheese

dough balls stuffed with pepperoni and cheese - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Flatten a piece of dough and place a slice of pepperoni and a piece of the mozzarella onto the center.

Step 14: Form A Ball

dough balls - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Pull the dough around the pepperoni and cheese to form a ball.

Step 15: Arrange The Wreath

dough balls in a wreath - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Arrange the dough balls around the bowl on the parchment paper. Vary the size and placement as you wish.

Step 16: Let It Rise

dough ball in a wreath - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Remove the bowl. Cover the dough let and rise for another 30 minutes.

Step 17: Preheat The Oven

preheated oven - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Preheat the oven to 425 F.

Step 18: Brush With Garlic Butter

brushed with garlic butter - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Brush the wreath with half of the garlic butter.

Step 19: Bake The Wreath

baked dough wreath - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Bake in the preheated oven for 25 minutes or until golden brown and puffed.

Step 20: Add The Parsley

parlsey in garlic butter - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Add the parsley to the remaining garlic butter.

Step 21: Brush With More Garlic Butter

baked wreath with garlic butter - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Brush the remaining garlic butter over the baked wreath.

Step 22: Add Garnish

baked wreath garnished with herbs - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Add rosemary and sundried tomatoes as garnish.

Step 23: Serve With Marinara

marinara sauce with baked bread - Leah Maroney/Tasting Table

Fill the small bowl with warm marinara sauce, set in the center of the wreath, and serve.

Can I Make This Pull-Apart Bread In Advance?

If you want to save time before your holiday party, you can make the dough for this pull-apart wreath recipe ahead of time. Just store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 4 days -- though it's recommended that you use it within 48 hours. It's also suggested that you let it rise for about half an hour before refrigerating. It will rise while it's in the fridge, so be sure to use a spacious container. Let the dough rest on the counter for a few minutes before shaping into balls and continuing with the recipe.

Once the dough wreath has been assembled, you can also freeze it right on the baking tray covered in plastic wrap for up to 6 months. It will take a little longer to bake once you are ready to eat it. You can also freeze it after it has baked and cooled. Wrap it in plastic wrap and freeze on the baking sheet so it stays flat. Once the wreath is baked it can also be stored in the refrigerator for up to 4 days and then reheated in a 375 F oven until hot. Though it is best served hot so that the cheese is still gooey, it can be served at room temperature as well.

Can I Adapt The Fillings In This Pull-Apart Bread?

The possibilities for stuffing this pull-apart wreath bread are endless! If you're a vegetarian you can replace the pepperoni with some extra sun-dried tomatoes or roasted red peppers. Spinach and artichoke dip also makes a great vegetarian stuffing. Simply scoop some of the dip onto the dough and wrap it up into a ball. This works best when the dip is cold, as it will be easier to scoop and will hold its shape better. You can also stuff the dough balls with cooked Italian sausage and mozzarella cheese. Ricotta cheese and mozzarella cheese can also be used to make a calzone-style bread.

Different dips can also be used for this bread. Serve it with an alfredo sauce, vodka sauce, or a basil pesto. You can even make this tasty recipe for a special holiday breakfast. Fill it with breakfast sausage and scrambled eggs and serve it with maple syrup or homemade country gravy. You can make it ahead of time and throw it in the oven on Christmas morning for an easy and delicious breakfast treat that won't take you away from the holiday festivities.