The Link Between Sugar and ADHD
Catherine Falls Commercial / Getty Images
Medically reviewed by Daniel B. Block, MDMedically reviewed by Daniel B. Block, MD
The idea that sugar can cause attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) or make ADHD symptoms worse is a pervasive myth that continues to be widely believed despite a growing body of research that suggests it simply isn’t true. This persistent belief is likely because there seems to be a link between sugar consumption and hyperactivity in children.
In this article, we’ll look at what the science says about the link between sugar and ADHD and what you can do about your sugar intake if you feel it’s negatively impacting your mental health.
Sugar Does Not Cause ADHD
Sugar can cause a burst of energy, popularly known as a sugar rush, but this should not be confused with ADHD-related hyperactivity. Studies on the connection between sugar and ADHD have found little to no evidence that sugar directly influences ADHD symptoms, let alone causes the neurodevelopmental disorder.
The evidence does suggest that there is a positive association between sugar intake—particularly from sweetened beverages—and specific ADHD symptoms. However, association does not mean one causes the other.
In a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies on the relationship between ADHD and sugar, researchers found a positive association between sugar-sweetened beverages and AHDH risk; however, "dietary sugar alone did not increase the risk of developing ADHD symptoms." This means that other variables may be involved, and more well-designed research studies are needed to isolate the different contributing factors.
Takeaway
In other words, people who consumed more sugar-sweetened beverages were more likely to have ADHD symptoms than those who didn’t, but sugar was not proven to be the cause of the increased ADHD risk.
Another meta-analysis on the effects of sugar on behavior and cognition concluded that sugar had no effect on cognitive performance or behavior and that the strong belief among caretakers that there was an effect was likely due to the expectation that sugar does cause hyperactivity and other symptoms.
The authors noted that a small subset of children may respond in idiosyncratic ways to sugar or have rare allergic reactions, but this is the exception and not the rule.
Explainer
While some of the studies included in these reviews did conclude that sugar intake contributed to ADHD symptoms, there were too many confounding factors to draw any firm conclusions.
For one, many studies relied on information from questionnaires given to parents or caretakers of children with ADHD rather than direct observation or interviews with the subjects with ADHD. Research shows that parents who expect sugar to make their children hyperactive are more likely to perceive their children as hyperactive after consuming sugar than an outside observer.
Explainer
One study even found that just telling parents that their children had consumed sugar even though they hadn’t resulted in those parents rating their children as more hyperactive.
Another confounding factor is that the sugary foods and beverages consumed contain many other ingredients, including caffeine and micronutrients, that could also impact energy levels and behavior. So, determining the role that sugar specifically played is hard.
Related: The Experts Agree: What You Eat Can Directly Impact Stress and Anxiety
Understanding the Relationship Between Sugar and ADHD
There may not be enough evidence to say that sugar is a direct cause of ADHD, but what does that “positive association” mean then? Right now, there’s not enough data to say with certainty how sugar impacts ADHD, but researchers do have some theories.
Sugary Diets Are Also Low in Nutrients
One of the leading theories is that ADHD symptoms are made worse by nutritional deficiencies, and diets high in sugary foods and beverages tend to also be low in nutritious foods. Many studies evaluated the intake specifically of refined sugar, which is found in processed sugary foods like juice, soda, candy, and desserts.
These processed foods tend to contain higher quantities of sugar (such as high fructose corn syrup) than naturally occurring sweet foods like fruit, and they also contain less fiber, protein, and other nutrients that the body needs to function.
One systematic review of the relationship between diet and ADHD found that while a nutrient-lacking diet didn’t necessarily make symptoms worse, a nutritious diet tended to have a “protective effect” against ADHD in the form of reducing symptom severity.
Takeaway
In other words, nutrient-poor diets don’t cause ADHD, but they do leave people with ADHD more vulnerable to the symptoms of their disorder.
For example, people with ADHD often have lower levels of iron and zinc, both of which play a role in regulating dopamine function. A diet high in sugary, nutrient-lacking processed foods isn’t providing the iron and zinc people with ADHD need to increase levels of those key dopamine regulators.
Sugar Activates the Dopamine System
Another theory is that increased sugar intake is a consequence, rather than a cause, of ADHD. Impulsivity and the preference for immediate rewards rather than delayed rewards make people with ADHD prone to crave sugary foods because sugar triggers a dopamine response in the brain.
Because the dopamine system is already severely dysregulated in ADHD, sugar’s ability to activate it might lead to a kind of self-medicating behavior where people with ADHD consume sugary foods or drinks in order to compensate for low dopamine levels. According to this theory, then, sugar isn’t the cause of ADHD symptoms; it’s an attempt—conscious or unconscious—to treat them.
Related: Why Do I Crave Sugar and Sweets? 4 Potential Causes
How to Cut Back on Sugar and Switch to an ADHD-Protective Diet
Even if a diet high in sugar doesn’t cause ADHD, it can cause plenty of other health problems like heart disease and tooth decay. Likewise, even though a healthy diet won’t cure your ADHD, it can make your symptoms easier to manage. So, it’s still worth cutting back on sugar and replacing processed foods with more nutritious items. Here are a few ADHD-friendly tips for reducing sugar and improving your diet.
Don’t Keep Sugary Snacks in the House
Impulse control is hard for people with ADHD. On the upside, object permanence is also challenging, so if the sugary snacks aren’t right in front of you, you might not think about them as much. If you can’t ignore the craving, keeping them out of the house at least makes the sugary snack harder to get.
If possible, enforce a rule that you must walk or bike to the store to pick up the snack (and only buy enough to indulge the current craving). Physical activity may help boost dopamine levels sufficiently enough to make the craving less intense. If not, at least you get some exercise before eating something sugary.
Eat a Fruit or Vegetable first
ADHD brains can be stubborn once they fixate on a reward they want (like the cookies you’re craving), so it can be hard to ignore a craving. But if you eat a big handful of carrots or an entire banana before you reach for the cookies, eating a smaller portion of the sugary snack can be easier.
Activate Your Reward System for Better Health
Rewarding yourself after a healthy snack might help you maintain healthier dietary habits in the long run because you’re effectively rewarding yourself with a dopamine-releasing cookie every time you eat a fruit or veggie. At the very least, it ensures you’re getting some nutrient-rich foods into your diet, even if you’re not yet ready to give up your favorite snacks.
By the same token, drink a glass of water before a sugary beverage. When you’re thirsty and craving soda or juice, fill your glass with water first. Chug that and then pour in the juice or soda. By the time you start drinking the juice or soda, you can sip it to savor the taste rather than gulping it down to quench your thirst.
Related: Understanding Binge Eating and ADHD
Don’t Overcomplicate It with Strict Diets
Having ADHD can make sticking to even the simplest routine seem impossible. Hence, a rigid diet where you’re denying yourself entire food categories or meticulously counting calories is not ideal. Instead of adhering to a completely unfamiliar and strict diet plan, take it one step at a time and opt for simple changes.
You don’t have to give up your favorite sugary foods; try to gradually eat less of them than usual. You don’t have to stock up on the latest expensive superfood; buy some carrots, apples, and other produce that doesn’t spoil too quickly, and make sure those are the first things you see when you open the fridge.
Experiment With Alternative Dopamine Boosters
Since the sugar craving might be your brain’s way of saying it’s low on dopamine, finding other ways to boost dopamine levels can help address that problem without resorting to sugar. Some dopamine-boosting alternatives to sugar include:
Spicy or flavorful foods. Peppers and other foods that cause a burning sensation also trigger the release of dopamine and endorphins. If you can’t stand the heat, some research suggests that other aromatic herbs and spices like rosemary, sage, lavender, cinnamon, nutmeg, and so on provide a similar dopamine-boosting effect.
Fun physical activity. Exercise is one of the most well-researched ways to boost dopamine levels. “Working out” might sound like an unbearable chore, but there are many ways to incorporate regular exercise into your day without even glancing at a treadmill. Dance around the house to your favorite playlist when you’re getting ready in the morning. Go for a walk in a nearby park during lunch. Try hiking, horseback riding, tennis, surfing, gymnastics, or any activity that catches your interest on the weekends.
Go outside in the sunlight. Some research suggests that sunlight may increase dopamine synthesis. Find ways to move some of your daily activities outdoors during the day. Move your coffee date to the park. Grab your laptop and answer emails while sitting on the bench outside your office. Head out to your backyard to take that phone call. Just remember to wear sunscreen.
In the long run, incorporating more of these activities and foods into your daily routine may help reduce your sugar cravings.
Related: ADHD Diet for Kids
Read the original article on Verywell Mind.
