Robbie Williams Song Dropped From 2025 Oscar Shortlist: Here’s Why
Robbie Williams’ “Forbidden Road” was removed from the 2025 Oscar shortlist for best original song on the grounds that it incorporates material from an existing song that was not written for the film in which it appears, Better Man (Paramount Pictures). Williams co-wrote the song with Freddy Wexler and Sacha Skarbek.
The song has already been removed from the list of shortlisted songs that appears on the Oscars site. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences will not replace the song on the shortlist. Members of the music branch will choose the five nominees from a shortlist of 14 songs, rather than the customary 15.
More from Billboard
Here’s the text of a letter sent to Academy’s music branch members from the branch’s executive committee, explaining the decision:
“Dear Music Branch members,
The shortlisted Original Song achievement, “Forbidden Road,” from the film BETTER MAN, incorporates material from an existing song that was not written for this film.
The Music Branch Executive Committee has met and reviewed materials. It was determined the achievement does not meet the 97th Awards Rules criteria for eligibility in the Original Song category: An original song consists of words and music, both of which are original and written specifically for the motion picture. [Rule Eighteen, Section 1-B].
Therefore, the song has been deemed ineligible for award consideration for the 97th Oscars and will be removed from the Academy’s shortlist in the Original Song category.
This is a decision that both honors our rules and protects the special nature of the Original Song and Score categories.
Sincerely,
The Music Branch Executive Committee”
The Academy’s letter did not name the song that “Forbidden Road” was found to have similarities to, but an Academy representative confirmed to Rolling Stone that the song is “I Got a Name,” the reflective, midtempo ballad which Jim Croce recorded for the 1973 film The Last American Hero. The song was co-written by Charles Fox, 84, who is on the Academy’s 55-person board of governors. He is one of the three governors representing the music branch (along with composers Lesley Barber and Richard Gibbs). The song’s other co-writer was Norman Gimbel, who died in 2018 at age 91.
The Last American Hero, which starred Jeff Bridges, was released in July 1973. “I Got a Name” was released as a single on Sept, 21, 1973, the day after Croce died in a plane crash in Louisiana at age 30. The song reached No. 10 on the Billboard Hot 100. It was, rather surprisingly, not nominated for an Oscar or a Golden Globe for best original song.
The Oscars run a very tight ship. Eleven years ago, a nominated songwriter, Bruce Broughton, was overzealous in promoting his song, running afoul of Academy regulations. The Academy rescinded the nomination. The explanation of what happened still appears on the Oscars site all these years later: “After the nominations were announced on January 16, 2014, it was determined that Mr. Broughton had taken actions in promoting the song that were inconsistent with the Academy’s campaign regulations. The Board of Governors voted to rescind the nomination on January 29, and only four songs were included on the final ballot.”
“Better Man” was nominated for a Golden Globe for best original song on Dec. 9, and will remain a nominee. A Golden Globes spokesperson said “Under the 82nd Annual Golden Globes eligibility and consideration rules, his song remains eligible.” Here’s the relevant clause from the rules: “Songs which contain words or music from prior songs (i.e., ‘sampling’) may be eligible if the Golden Globe eligibility committee determines that the copied portions of prior songs do not alter the overall originality of the song.”
Better Man will have a limited release opening on Christmas Day. It will go wide on Jan. 10. Williams is portrayed by a computer-generated monkey in this film about his life which was co-written, produced and directed by Michael Gracey.
Best of Billboard
Sign up for Billboard's Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.
Solve the daily Crossword
