Rami Malek's response to question about Freddie Mercury being a gay icon doesn't go so well
Bohemian Rhapsody has had no shortage of drama and now people are talking about Rami Malek‘s answer to a question about Freddie Mercury’s sexuality.
The movie’s star was asked by INTO if he saw Mercury as a gay icon, amid criticism that the rock star’s sexuality is played down in the film, which opens Nov. 2 in the U.S. Malek took a moment to find the right words.
The new film 'Bohemian Rhapsody' hasn't even been released and there's been controversy around the de-queering of Freddie Mercury.
We sat down with Rami Malek before the film's release to ask about this.
And his answer, um, didn't help https://t.co/ASjQnkhLHq pic.twitter.com/yIfEB35OgD
— Zach Stafford (@ZachStafford) October 23, 2018
“Um… I don’t — I think the way…” he began. “What’s really great about him is that he never, uh, wanted to or thought of himself as being boxed into anything. … I’ve heard him say, you know, when asked, he says, ‘I’m just me. I’m just me.’ So ‘icon’ — I think it encompasses whatever the way you identify, I think. If he’s an icon to one, there’s no reason that it, uh, requires another adjective as far as I see.”
That post kicked off many comments about Malek’s reply. While the editor-in-chief of INTO, who posted the clip, clearly didn’t like the answer — or “non-answer,” as some called it — others agreed.
Rami… pic.twitter.com/eQ7IuaIbGC
— Captain Beardwolf 🌈 (@campelo79) October 23, 2018
Cringe.
— Harry Cook (@HarryCook) October 23, 2018
Wouldn’t it have been easier and less words to just say “yes”
— Bwk (@TheRealBwk) October 24, 2018
One issue was that in Malek’s answer, he didn’t even say the word gay (or bisexual or pansexual).
He asked if he was a gay icon, not even what his sexuality was, and still it was just to much, he had to go down the path of no labels aka don't mention the g word 🙄
— Dany Savovic🏳??🌈 (@d818581dany) October 25, 2018
“saw himself boxed into anything”, everybody and they momma out here so afraid to say the word gay, or bi, or queer. pic.twitter.com/ycQcb4I2HL
— Joshua Caleb (@lukewarmsushii) October 23, 2018
But people defended him, noting Mercury didn’t like to label himself. He was a star at a different time.
I think Rami response is perfect actually. Freddie never identified as one specific, he was free and loved life. He had support from his parents and friends with his choices for love & career. So no, your interview was wrong to try and box an icon that did not box himself👍
— Magsimoo (@TheMagsimoo) October 25, 2018
Freddie never announced his sexuality and he wanted it kept that way. Rami is respecting his wishes, the end
— 𝖍𝖞𝖕𝖓𝖔𝖙𝖎𝖈 💉 (@thepurestsoul_) October 24, 2018
If by "didn't help," you mean he described how Freddie actually acted regarding his sexuality (5 on the Kinsey) rather than just saying "yes, gay gay gay," then yeah, it didn't help. It seems like you're offended that Freddie wasn't being described as the right kind of queer.
— EA Solinas (@easolinas) October 24, 2018
And some suggested that Malek had studied Mercury so thoroughly that he was answering the way Mercury would have.
Really? Have you watched Freddie in interviews? Rami has spent so much time being him, he's becoming him. This is how Freddie answered questions like this so it's quite authentic.
— ??ArwenXavier (@PhoenixMagic24) October 24, 2018
anywaaaay, of course you can call freddie a gay icon, because he did help lots of people accept who they are & thats valid! rami is a sweetheart was just trying to be respectful, NEXT pic.twitter.com/w24xDaUr4F
— chloe ? 9 (@holtmycaptain) October 23, 2018
Stop saying that Rami Malek is homophobic because he doesn't want to call freddie mercury a gay icon because he doesn't want to put him in a box,when Freddie HIMSELF didn't want to be put in a box either. Mercury was/is just A ICON! Malek just respecting the man’s choices pic.twitter.com/8mDa0pewiQ
— Hope (@hopie234) October 24, 2018
It was also noted that the movie does depict Mercury’s relationships with men.
I haven't seen the film, but I have seen clips of Rami's Freddie kissing men, and interviews with the actor playing Freddie's longtime boyfriend Jim Hutton, so I'd say it's shown in the movie.
— Raven (@theravenmonroe) October 24, 2018
Some raised the point that the movie was about Queen the band and just not Mercury’s sexual orientation.
he never labeled himself. rami is correct. he’s done so much research, which even included hours and hours of conversations with freddie’s mother. my mom actually got to hear him talk about all of this. the film isn’t just about freddie mercury and his sexuality. it’s about queen
— sam sam sam (@samcapskates) October 24, 2018
Others asked why he had to be labeled at all.
And, as a bisexual person, I often wonder why you guys are so… adamant, sort of, that we don't exist. That we're all gay or straight and just lying or being dishonest. That's what this feels like. Why does he need to be a GAY icon? Why not a bi-icon?
— Raven (@theravenmonroe) October 24, 2018
1) Didn't it occur to anyone that Rami may feel uncomfortable labelling someone who, not only isn't here to speak for themselves, but also, didn't like to be labelled??
2) Freddie Mercury was with women too. This is bi erasure.— L (@HollyHoelightly) October 24, 2018
People felt Malek was wrongly being criticized, given that he helped bring this story to the big screen.
How about you focus on real issues of true homphobia instead of bashing a man who has spent years of his life bringing the story of a very flamboyant gay/bi man to life? Obviously someone who does that is not homophobic so lay off and find a better fight. 🙄
— ??ArwenXavier (@PhoenixMagic24) October 26, 2018
And there was at least one Megyn Kelly reference.
Chileeee asking a straight actor to answer or validate a gay icon is like asking megyn kelly about the black experience. Super awkward
— Jason Clark-Fox (@baby_face_alpha) October 24, 2018
But many weren’t appeased by his answer.
It's easy not to care when you're not the one being erased.
— Information Please🌈 (@informationplz_) October 24, 2018
We'll stay triggered. It's perfectly acceptable for people to talk about societal norms rooted in homohobia of the time period, and how they'd relate to Freddie not wanting to disclose his sexuality. I think some of his fans are embarassed he was into men..
— Dany Savovic🏳??🌈 (@d818581dany) October 25, 2018
Some even said they wouldn’t see the film. Yes, the “b” word.
boycott this movie
— A STAR IS BORN SNAPPED. (@numbillusion) October 24, 2018
Malek and the film have been accused of straight-washing from the start, and the actor addressed it in an interview in September. He called it a “shame” that people were “making remarks” after the one-minute teaser was first released — “where you just wanna see the music,” as Malek told Attitude. Describing the topic as “difficult,” he defended the movie’s treatment of the subject. “Let me say that I don’t think the film shies away from his sexuality or his all-consuming disease, which is obviously AIDS. I don’t know how you could avoid any of that, or if anyone would ever want to.”
Talking about Mercury’s battle’s with AIDS, Malek added, “The film needed to approach it in a delicate manner. You can’t shy away from it. It was an important moment to have in the film, one that ultimately is very sad but also empowering in a way. It shows you just how resilient human beings can be and how much we rely on the strength of our friends and family to get us through tough times. This pandemic is still very much a horrific threat to so many people in the world. It exists as a reality for so many that I think it would be a shame not to address it.”
Of course, another big drama related to the film was the fact that its director, Bryan Singer, was fired during production. Here’s how Malek address that in an interview with Yahoo Entertainment:
Read more from Yahoo Entertainment: